Newman's Own Organics Grain-Free Beef Canned Cat Food
In a Nutshell
- Many cats refused to eat this food due to its texture and fat content.
- Newman's stared organically flourished flavors.
- Customer service’s coupons’ are not practically compensating for financial loss.
Quick Verdict
While some cats enjoy it, many owners and cats are not satisfied with the texture, fat content, and lack of sauce. The beef is sourced from Uruguay, contrary to the label. The brand's customer service is noted as unhelpful.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Critical Warnings
High fat content may be unsuitable for cats with specific dietary concerns.
Prevention: Avoid feeding this product to cats with dietary concerns.
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
Organic Compositions (3)
It is a healthy-organic rich food far from artificial compositions.
-
Chicken Cat Food (2)
It was critiqued that chicken flavors are far more palatable.
Cons
-
Too Much Fat (3) major
Many cats and owners were disappointed in unsatisfactory fat levels.
-
Lack of Sauce (2) major
The absence of sauce made it unpalatable.
-
Unexpected Beef Origin (2) major
The beef is from Uruguay, not the USA as labeled.
-
Unhelpful Customer Service (1) minor
Customer service offers coupons instead of refunds.
-
Discontinued Product (1) major
The product has been discontinued, possibly due to poor reception.
Quality Trend: Declining
A notable sentiment shift from positive to negative.
positive
negative
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
- • Cat owners seeking a grain-free option — It is 100% beef with no preservatives or carbohydrates, suitable for cats with specific dietary needs.
✗ Skip If
- • Cat owners concerned about high-fat content — Many reviewers mentioned the product being too fatty and unpalatable.
Durability & Care
Cleaning Methods
Care Tips from Users
- 💡 Feed in smaller portions to monitor acceptance.
Rating Distribution
Common Questions
Does this product contain any preservatives or carbohydrates?
No, it is 100% beef with no preservatives or carbohydrates.
Is the beef sourced from the USA?
No, the beef is sourced from Uruguay in contrast to the label.
Does this product have a sauce?
No, it is a dense pate with no sauce.
Highlighted Reviews
"My kitties just loved it an I love the fact that it doesn't seem greasy, kitties love the taste, and it's healthy!"
"First, it says the product is made in USA but in fact the beef is from Uruguay. 2nd, it is pate & description said it had a sauce to it, like most pates. When I opened the can to find a very dense pate with absolutely no sauce to even make it worth eating, it had about a tablespoon of solidified fat..."
Bottom Line
Contact Newman's Own for coupons or a refund if unsatisfied, as the problem seems to be inherent to this batch. Seek different textures and compositions if your cat normally enjoys mixed menus, and for exceptional cat nutrition results.