Pet Treats Strong Smell High Price Point High repeat purchase rate
Bocce's Bakery Merry Fish-Mas Ornament Salmon & Sweet Potato Limited Ingredient Crunchy Cat Treats, 1-oz box

Bocce's Bakery Merry Fish-Mas Ornament Salmon & Sweet Potato Limited Ingredient Crunchy Cat Treats, 1-oz box

By Bocce's Bakery 10 reviews analyzed Updated Oct 2023 85% confidence
6.9 /10
Quality
6.0
Value
4.5
Design
7.0
Function
7.5
Durability
6.0

In a Nutshell

  • Mixed feelings about the strong fishy smell.
  • Cats generally love the treat.
  • High price point and low quantity per package are common complaints.

Quick Verdict

Bocce's Bakery Merry Fish-Mas treats are a hit with picky cats but the strong fishy smell is a deterrent for some. The high price point is also a concern for many buyers. The treats are especially liked for their limited ingredients and for helping with dry fur in colder weather.

Quick Stats

Reviews Analyzed 10
Would Recommend 75%
Would Buy Again 40%
Avg Lifespan One box / Several treats

Pet Compatibility

πŸ• Dogs
Caution
🐈 Cats
Suitable

Critical Warnings

high

Make sure cats aren’t allergic to seafood, if they are, this could be harmful.

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Limited Ingredients (3)

    The treats have a limited ingredient list, making them suitable for cats with dietary restrictions.

  • Cats Love Them (3)

    Many cats, including picky ones, enjoy the taste of these treats.

  • Addresses Dry Fur (1)

    The treats are helpful in managing dry fur, especially in colder weather.

  • Festive Packaging (2)

    The packaging is cute and appealing, adding to the festive atmosphere.

Cons

  • Strong Smell (7) critical

    The treats have a very strong and unpleasant fishy smell.

  • High Price (4) major

    The treats are expensive, and the quantity per package is small.

  • Inconsistent Packaging (2) major

    The product uses the same festive packaging year-round, which some buyers dislike.

    Tip: Change packaging during non-festive seasons.

  • Disinterest from Cats (4) critical

    Some cats show no interest in these treats.

Who Is This For?

βœ“ Best For

  • β€’ Cat owners with picky eaters β€” These treats are likable to picky cats and helps with dry fur in colder weather.
  • β€’ Occasional treat seekers β€” Though high in price, these treats can be a good occasional indulgence, especially holiday-themed

βœ— Skip If

  • β€’ Budget-conscious buyers β€” The high price and small quantity make these treats less affordable.
  • β€’ Owners sensitive to strong smells β€” The strong fishy smell can be off-putting to both owners and cats.

Durability & Care

Expected Lifespan One box

Factors:

Cleaning Methods

βœ— Machine wash
βœ— Hand wash
βœ— Spot clean

Floor Compatibility

βœ“ Hardwood
βœ“ Tile
βœ“ Carpet
βœ“ Vinyl
βœ“ Laminate

Rating Distribution

2.7
10 reviews
5β˜…
40%
4β˜…
10%
3β˜…
0%
2β˜…
0%
1β˜…
50%
limited ingredients (3) cute packaging (2) fishy smell (7) high prices (4)

Common Questions

Are these treats suitable for picky cats?

Yes, many picky cats love these treats.

Do these treats have a strong smell?

Yes, they have a strong fishy smell.

Are these treats good for dry fur?

Yes, they are effective in managing dry fur, especially in colder weather.

Highlighted Reviews

β€” Bethany

"My cat loves these treats and if she sees them in my hand follows me nonstop. She is picky with her cat treats so these are a win."

β€” Chelsea

"These smelled VERY fishy and my cat wouldn't eat them at all. He's very picky so I'm not blaming the treats per say but 1 star bc they were potent."

Bottom Line

If you can overlook the strong smell and the high price, these treats are a good option for spoiling your cat, especially during holidays or as an occasional treat. However, for everyday use, consider more affordable alternatives.

6.9 /10
β€” Below Average