Firstmate 50/50 Chicken & Tuna Formula Grain-Free Canned Cat Food
In a Nutshell
- Grain-free and juicy, made in Canada without carrageenan.
- Many cats reject the food, especially those dislike tuna.
- Storage issues reported, leading to soggy product arrival.
Quick Verdict
This grain-free canned cat food is noted for being juicy and free from harmful ingredients, but has a high rejection rate among cats, particularly those averse to tuna flavor.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Critical Warnings
Tuna smell may cause cats to refuse the food, leading to potential health issues if cats skip meals.
Prevention: Consider alternative flavors or brands.
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
Clean and Juicy (1)
The food is clean and juicy, which some pet owners prefer.
-
Good Packaging (1)
Well portioned and clean
Cons
-
Unappealing to Cats (2) critical
Many cats, even non-picky eaters, refuse to eat this food, especially due to the tuna smell.
-
Storage and Handling Issues (1) major
The food often arrives soggy and not properly stored.
Tip: Improved storage and handling practices by Chewy.
Quality Trend: Declining
Review trend declining, especially recent reviews.
average
negative
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
- • Health-conscious pet owners — The food is grain-free and made in Canada.
✗ Skip If
- • Cats that dislike tuna smell — Many cats refuse to eat this food due to the tuna smell.
- • Pet owners concerned about food quality — There are complaints about the product arriving soggy and not properly stored.
Durability & Care
Cleaning Methods
Floor Compatibility
Rating Distribution
Highlighted Reviews
"easy to portion"
"food showed up very soggy and almost entirely in a liquid form in some instances"
Bottom Line
While the food is clean and well-made, the tuna smell is a deal-breaker for many cats. Consider alternative flavors if your cat is averse to tuna.