Pet Food Quality Concerns
Firstmate 50/50 Chicken & Tuna Formula Grain-Free Canned Cat Food

Firstmate 50/50 Chicken & Tuna Formula Grain-Free Canned Cat Food

By Firstmate 5 reviews analyzed Updated Oct 2023 80% confidence
3.2 /10
Quality
4.0
Value
3.5
Design
3.0
Function
3.0
Durability
2.0

In a Nutshell

  • Grain-free and juicy, made in Canada without carrageenan.
  • Many cats reject the food, especially those dislike tuna.
  • Storage issues reported, leading to soggy product arrival.

Quick Verdict

This grain-free canned cat food is noted for being juicy and free from harmful ingredients, but has a high rejection rate among cats, particularly those averse to tuna flavor.

Quick Stats

Reviews Analyzed 5
Would Recommend 0%
Would Buy Again 20%

Pet Compatibility

🐕 Dogs
Caution
🐈 Cats
Caution

Critical Warnings

high

Tuna smell may cause cats to refuse the food, leading to potential health issues if cats skip meals.

Prevention: Consider alternative flavors or brands.

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Clean and Juicy (1)

    The food is clean and juicy, which some pet owners prefer.

  • Good Packaging (1)

    Well portioned and clean

Cons

  • Unappealing to Cats (2) critical

    Many cats, even non-picky eaters, refuse to eat this food, especially due to the tuna smell.

  • Storage and Handling Issues (1) major

    The food often arrives soggy and not properly stored.

    Tip: Improved storage and handling practices by Chewy.

Quality Trend: Declining

Review trend declining, especially recent reviews.

Older Reviews Said:

average

Newer Reviews Say:

negative

Who Is This For?

Best For

  • Health-conscious pet owners — The food is grain-free and made in Canada.

Skip If

  • Cats that dislike tuna smell — Many cats refuse to eat this food due to the tuna smell.
  • Pet owners concerned about food quality — There are complaints about the product arriving soggy and not properly stored.

Durability & Care

Expected Lifespan Varies

Cleaning Methods

Machine wash
Hand wash
Spot clean

Floor Compatibility

⚠️ Hardwood
⚠️ Tile
⚠️ Carpet
⚠️ Vinyl
⚠️ Laminate

Rating Distribution

2.2
5 reviews
5★
20%
4★
20%
3★
0%
2★
20%
1★
40%

Highlighted Reviews

— Maffy 3 found helpful

"easy to portion"

— ConcernedCatParent

"food showed up very soggy and almost entirely in a liquid form in some instances"

Bottom Line

While the food is clean and well-made, the tuna smell is a deal-breaker for many cats. Consider alternative flavors if your cat is averse to tuna.

3.2 /10
Below Average