Solid Gold Wholesome Selects with Real Chicken & Liver Recipe in Gravy Grain-Free Canned Cat Food, 3-oz, case of 12
In a Nutshell
- Mixed taste appeal among cats
- Some cats lose weight after consumption
- Recommended as an occasional treat or top dressing
- Price is reasonable for some, but overall quality is inconsistent
Quick Verdict
The Solid Gold Wholesome Selects wet cat food receives mixed feedback. Some cats enjoy it, while others find the texture unappetizing. Price and quality vary by reviewer.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Critical Warnings
Weight loss in cats
Prevention: Combine with regular dry food when using
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
Affordable Pricing (1)
Some reviewers found the product to be a good value, especially when bought in bulk.
-
Grain-Free Recipe (1)
Grain-free formula may be beneficial for cats with dietary restrictions.
-
Acceptable by Some Cats (3)
A notable number of cats do enjoy this food, especially as a top dressing.
-
Good Quality Control (1)
Some reviewers mentioned that the product appears to be well-made.
Cons
-
Dissuaded Cats (4) major
Many cats refused to eat this cat food, leading to food waste and disappointment among owners.
-
Weight Loss Issues (1) critical
Some cats lost a significant amount of weight while consuming this food, raising health concerns.
-
Packaging Concerns (1) minor
Concerns raised about the packaging and potential for dealing with the product.
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
- • Owners of cats needing a grain-free diet — Specific grain-free formula might be helpful.
- • Cats that struggle with other foods — Some cats enjoy this food despite others not liking it
✗ Skip If
- • Owners of picky eaters — Many cats refused to eat this food leading.
- • Cats prone to weight loss — Noted that cats experienced weight loss when consuming this food.
Durability & Care
Factors: Size of Cats
Care Tips from Users
- 💡 Refrigerate after opening
- 💡 Use within a week of opening
Floor Compatibility
Rating Distribution
Common Questions
Is this food suitable for cats with allergies?
Mentioned ingredients may concern and cause warning.
Highlighted Reviews
"Both of my cats enjoy this chicken & liver recipe. Not sure why ratings are low for it. Quality is consistently good and price isn't bad. Works for us!"
"Upon closer re iew this product contains ingredients I try to avoid feeding my Maine Coons. I actually went into my AutoShip and removed this item...I was charged for the old and edited AutoShip amounts...I will not ever do AutoShip again."
Bottom Line
The product is a hit or miss with cats. Consider as an occasional treat or top dressing, as one reviewer recommends, due to mixed taste preferences from cats. Else, explore alternatives that more reliably satisfy your pet’s taste.