Dog Treats Trending Down
Redbarn Premium 5'' Bully Stick Dog Treat

Redbarn Premium 5'' Bully Stick Dog Treat

By Redbarn 9 reviews analyzed Updated Oct 2023 85% confidence
6.5 /10
Quality
5.0
Value
5.5
Design
6.0
Function
7.0
Durability
5.5

In a Nutshell

  • Some dogs love these bully sticks for their chewing satisfaction.
  • Consistent complaints about thin sticks and strong odors.
  • Quality seems to have declined over time.

Quick Verdict

While some dogs enjoy these bully sticks, there are consistent reports of thin, low-quality sticks and occasional strong odors. Overall, it's a mixed bag with noticeable issues that could deter repeat purchases.

Quick Stats

Reviews Analyzed 9
Would Recommend 78%
Would Buy Again 78%
Avg Lifespan 45 minutes

Pet Compatibility

🐕 Dogs
Suitable
🐈 Cats
Caution

Critical Warnings

critical

Thinner and less durable sticks pose potential choking hazards for dogs, particularly smaller breeds.

Prevention: Inspect each stick for thickness and durability before giving it to your dog.

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Chewing Satisfaction (3)

    Dogs enjoy chewing on these sticks for extended periods.

  • Keeps Dogs Busy (2)

    Perfect for keeping dogs occupied while owners enjoy their time.

  • Saves Furniture and Clothes (1)

    Helps in reducing destructive chewing behavior.

Cons

  • Thin and Poorly Constructed (4) major

    Many sticks are thin and poorly made, not meeting the expected quality.

  • Strong and Unpleasant Odor (2) major

    Some sticks have a strong, unpleasant smell like cow dung.

  • Shrinking Quality (3) major

    Quality seems to have declined over time.

Quality Trend: Declining

Users have reported thinner, less durable sticks in recent purchases, suggesting a decline in quality control.

Older Reviews Said:

positive

Newer Reviews Say:

negative

Who Is This For?

Best For

  • Dog owners looking for long-lasting chewing treats. — These bully sticks are valued for keeping dogs engaged and happy.

Skip If

  • Owners of small or large dogs who do not just want a quick snack. — The declining quality and potential choking hazard make these treats less appealing.

Durability & Care

Expected Lifespan 30 minutes to 1 hour

Factors: Size and strength of the dog, Quality and thickness of the stick

Cleaning Methods

Machine wash
Hand wash
Spot clean

Care Tips from Users

  • 💡 Store in a cool, dry place to maintain freshness.

Floor Compatibility

Hardwood
Tile
Carpet
Vinyl
Laminate

Rating Distribution

3.9
9 reviews
5★
56%
4★
11%
3★
22%
2★
0%
1★
22%
dog loves (3) long-lasting (2) thin (4) unpleasant smell (2) poor quality (3)

Highlighted Reviews

— Melanie

"My dogs absolutely love these bully sticks, and they last for about an hour with two 15 pound dogs."

— Amber

"I’ve bought the 5” bully sticks for my dog before and been satisfied, but I was very disappointed by my last order. The whole thing is pretty thing, compared to standard but one end is egregiously thin, about half the width of a pencil. Would not describe this as a premium product and am disappo..."

Bottom Line

If you're looking for a reliable, high-quality chew for your dog, consider exploring other brands. If you decide to try these, be prepared for potentially inconsistent quality.

6.5 /10
Below Average