Dog Treats Quality Concerns Caution Trending Down
Prairie Dog Odor Free 9" Bully Sticks Dog Treats

Prairie Dog Odor Free 9" Bully Sticks Dog Treats

9 reviews analyzed Updated Oct 2023 75% confidence
6.0 /10
Quality
5.7
Value
5.5
Design
6.0
Function
6.0
Durability
4.5

In a Nutshell

  • Dogs love the taste but have mixed reviews on quality.
  • Some treats are thin and not worth the price.
  • Odor issues contradict the 'odor-free' claim.
  • Good for medium to large dogs who are not aggressive chewers.
  • Quality consistency is a major concern.
  • Many reviews mention a noticeable urine-like smell.

Quick Verdict

These bully sticks are loved by dogs for their taste but have inconsistent quality and odor issues that can be a deal-breaker for some owners. The price is relatively high for the variability in quality.

Quick Stats

Reviews Analyzed 9
Would Recommend 56%
Would Buy Again 56%
Avg Lifespan About 20-60 minutes

Pet Compatibility

🐕 Dogs
Suitable

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Good Taste (8)

    Dogs love the taste and the texture of these bully sticks.

  • Long Lasting (7)

    These treats last a good amount of time, keeping dogs occupied.

  • Good Quality (5)

    When the quality is good, these are comparable to higher-priced options.

  • High Quality in Some Batches (1)

    Some batches are exactly what I'm looking for in a chew.

  • Best Chew Bones (2)

    Great size for their aggressiveness, would buy again.

Cons

  • Inconsistent Quality (4) major

    Quality varies widely, with some sticks being thin and hard to justify the price

    Tip: Contact the manufacturer for better quality control or choose an alternative product with more consistent quality.

  • Odor Issues (3) major

    Several reviews mention a noticeable urine-like smell, contradicting the odor-free claim.

    Tip: Consider using these treats in well-ventilated areas or avoiding them if odor is a significant concern.

  • Short Lifespan (2) minor

    Some reviewers noted that the treats did not last long, especially for aggressive chewers. Pully stick only lasted 30 minutes in our doggy world

    Tip: Purchase larger or more durable treats for aggressive chewers.

  • Poor Durability (1) major

    Some reviewers noted poor durability, especially for aggressive chewers. These only lasted about 20 minutes, it's nice to keep them occupied with them. These seem to be the cheapest for the length/size, and there's hardly any odor!.

    Tip: Popular with large dogs, except for the occasional soft ones. They are normally very hard and stay in tact for a long period of time, at which the dog has never rejected this treat.

Quality Trend: Declining

Recent reviews indicate a decline in quality, with more complaints about thin, pencil-like sticks and odor issues.

Older Reviews Said:

mostly positive

Newer Reviews Say:

mostly neutral and negative

Who Is This For?

Best For

  • Large dogs — These treats are good for dogs that aren't aggressive chewers and are of medium-large breed.
  • Owners looking for a treat that keeps their dogs occupied — These treats last a decent amount of time, keeping dogs occupied.

Skip If

  • Owners looking for a reliable and consistent product — There is a lack of consistency in quality and odor.
  • Owners who are sensitive to odors — Some reviewers noted a noticeable urine-like smell.

Durability & Care

Expected Lifespan 30 minutes to over 60 minutes

Factors: Dog temperments or behaviours

Cleaning Methods

Machine wash
Hand wash
Spot clean

Care Tips from Users

  • 💡 Odour-free
  • 💡 Keep occupied

Floor Compatibility

Hardwood
Tile
Carpet
Vinyl
Laminate

Rating Distribution

3.6
9 reviews
5★
56%
4★
0%
3★
0%
2★
11%
1★
33%
Durable (10) Odor-free (8) Good Taste (8) Poor Quality (10) High Price (3) Odour (7)

Common Questions

Are these bully sticks truly odor-free?

No, several reviewers mentioned a noticeable urine-like smell.

How long do these treats last for aggressive chewers?

They typically last about 20 minutes for aggressive chewers.

Should the scent affect me?

No, the scent will affect your doggy.

Are these treats suitable for small dogs or aggressive chewers,?

They are best for medium to large dogs who are not as aggressive, but they can chill and enjoy.

Highlighted Reviews

— BardleBee 5 found helpful

"This bully stick doesn't stain and is odorless. It was eaten pretty quickly, so I would recommend this for a medium size dog or dog that is not an aggressive chewer."

— Lulu

"I had high hopes for these bully sticks...but unfortunately, I will not be purchasing these again. They lasted not even 30 minutes with my puppy, who is a light chewer."

Bottom Line

If you're looking for a treat that your dog will enjoy but can tolerate some variability in quality and possible odor issues, these bully sticks are an option. However, for a more consistent and reliable dog treat, you may want to consider other options.

6.0 /10
Below Average