Barkworthies Extra Large Elk Antler 4 - 5" Dog Chew
In a Nutshell
- Durability varies, with some chews lasting significantly less time.
- Owners often feel the "Extra Large" description is misleading, as many antlers are much smaller than expected.
- Dogs generally enjoy it if the size is correct, but the quality can be inconsistent.
Quick Verdict
While some dogs love the taste, durability and size issues make this a questionable choice for many buyers.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
Durable (1)
Heavier chews can last well..
Cons
-
Misinleading size (3) critical
Antlers arrive significantly smaller than described
-
Durability (1) major
The chew splinters and separates easily, failing to last for extended periods
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
- • Dog owners with small to medium-sized dogs — Exclusive size
✗ Skip If
- • Owners of large or powerful chewers — Durability and sizing issues
Durability & Care
Factors: dog size, chewing strength
Cleaning Methods
Care Tips from Users
- 💡 Spot clean
Floor Compatibility
Rating Distribution
Common Questions
How durable?
Durability varies significantly; some chews last longer, but many users report them splintering within 40 mins
Highlighted Reviews
"My two dogs fight over these! They keep them busy for a long time!"
"I got the "XL" split antler. It is soooooo itty bitty teeny tiny. Barely 4", and very small in diameter. I like a lot of barkworthies products, but this one isn't worth the cost. I would rather pay a few more $ to get an antler that has some heft. This is barely puppy sized."
Bottom Line
Prices vary significantly, making it a good choice for smaller dogs, but not necessarily for larger ones. It seems to cater to dogs with specific size needs. If you have a range of dogs and likely to buy more than size would definitely consider. For those who specifically want to avoid heavy chewers, it seems to be reliable.