Pet Treats
I and Love and You Nothin' But Fish Grain-Free Cat Treats

I and Love and You Nothin' But Fish Grain-Free Cat Treats

By I and Love and You 2 reviews analyzed Updated Oct 2023 85% confidence
4.0 /10
Quality
4.0
Value
3.0
Design
3.5
Function
4.5
Durability
3.5

In a Nutshell

  • Cats enjoy the taste.
  • Product size has changed and is now smaller.
  • Pricier than other alternatives.

Quick Verdict

These grain-free cat treats are a hit with cats, but there are some concerns about the price and changing product size.

Quick Stats

Reviews Analyzed 2
Would Recommend 50%
Would Buy Again 100%
Avg Lifespan Not specified by reviewers.

Pet Compatibility

🐕 Dogs
Caution
🐈 Cats
Suitable

Critical Warnings

high

Very high compared to other pet treats.

Prevention: None.

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Taste appeal (2)

    Cats seem to love the fish flavoring.

  • Single ingredient (1)

    Made from a simple, straightforward, single ingredient.

Cons

  • Ease of availability (1) minor

    The product is difficult to find.

    Tip: Purchase online if not available locally.

  • Price (1) major

    The treats are on the expensive side.

  • Product size change (1) minor

    The size of the treats has changed, making them smaller and darker.

Quality Trend: Declining

The size and texture of the treats have changed, making them smaller and more styrofoam-like.

Older Reviews Said:

mixed

Newer Reviews Say:

mixed

Who Is This For?

Best For

  • Health-conscious cat owners — Single ingredient and fish flavor.

Skip If

  • Price-sensitive buyers — High cost.
  • Those preferring larger treats — Product size has changed and is now smaller.

Durability & Care

Expected Lifespan Not specified by reviewers.

Factors: storage conditions

Cleaning Methods

Machine wash
Hand wash
Spot clean

Floor Compatibility

Hardwood
Tile
Carpet
Vinyl
Laminate

Rating Distribution

4.0
2 reviews
5★
50%
4★
0%
3★
50%
2★
0%
1★
0%
taste (2)

Common Questions

What is the primary ingredient?

Fish, which cats enjoy.

Highlighted Reviews

— Sid 1 found helpful

"Both of my kitties loved it. I don't normally feed them food with any fish, so this was truly a treat and they were very happy with it. I really like that it is a simple, straightforward, single ingredient."

— Heidster

"This product is pretty hard to find now, glad I spotted here. The size of the product has changed...the pieces were larger and more styrofoam-like before, now they are much, much smaller bits that seem darker and more fishy. My crazy cats still like them, though I'm unsure why they changed the dehyd..."

Bottom Line

This product is worth trying if your cat loves fish-flavored treats and you don't mind the higher price. Keep an eye on the changing product size.

4.0 /10
Good