Cat Food Quality Issues Trending Down
Firstmate Wild Tuna Formula Limited Ingredient Grain-Free Canned Cat Food

Firstmate Wild Tuna Formula Limited Ingredient Grain-Free Canned Cat Food

By Firstmate 10 reviews analyzed Updated Oct 2023 85% confidence
6.7 /10
Quality
6.2
Value
6.5
Design
7.0
Function
6.0
Durability
6.0

In a Nutshell

  • Enjoys high praise for all-natural ingredients
  • Taste is a hit-and-miss among cats
  • Packaging can be difficult to open
  • Price may not justify for all users

Quick Verdict

This cat food has a mix of positive and negative reviews. Some cats love it, while others refuse to eat it. The ingredient quality is highly praised, but the packaging and smell after refrigeration are frequent complaints.

Quick Stats

Reviews Analyzed 10
Would Recommend 40%
Would Buy Again 40%

Pet Compatibility

šŸ• Dogs
Caution
🐈 Cats
Suitable

Critical Warnings

high

Some individuals have mentioned that their pets have problems with this food product.

Prevention: it suggested using this food as a probationary food

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • All-Natural Ingredients (1)

    Multiple reviewers praise the all-natural ingredients in this product.

  • Ease of Use (1)

    FirstMate supplement as a food rotation

  • Value (1)

    I’m using this product to try to wean her off.

Cons

  • Packaging Issues (2) major

    Difficulty in opening the cans reported by several reviewers.

    Tip: Users have resolved these issues by asking friends and family for assistance.

  • Taste and Smell (3) major

    Cats show dislike for the taste, primarily after refrigeration.

  • High Price (1) minor

    Some reviewers feel the price does not justify the value received.

Quality Trend: Declining

Recent reviews indicate a decrease in overall quality and satisfaction.

Older Reviews Said:

mixed

Newer Reviews Say:

negative

Who Is This For?

āœ“ Best For

  • • Cat owners looking for natural ingredients — Cats that have specific dietary needs.

āœ— Skip If

  • • Cat owners with picky eaters — The taste and smell might not be acceptable.

Durability & Care

Expected Lifespan except mix

Cleaning Methods

āœ— Machine wash
āœ— Hand wash
āœ— Spot clean

Care Tips from Users

  • šŸ’” freezing the food into mini ice cube trays and pull out what food it is needed.

Floor Compatibility

āœ“ Hardwood
āœ“ Tile
āš ļø Carpet
āœ“ Vinyl
āœ“ Laminate

Rating Distribution

2.9
10 reviews
5ā˜…
30%
4ā˜…
10%
3ā˜…
20%
2ā˜…
10%
1ā˜…
30%
ingreidents (1) minimalrod (1) hardtoop (1) distaste (1)

Common Questions

How long can an opened can of this food be stored?

It can be stored in mini ice cube trays and frozen for extended use.

Highlighted Reviews

— Dee

"All natural ingredients. When I bought this and took a tiny fork full, mixed the tiny bit in with it....SUCCESS!! Both kittens liked the bowl clean. "

— Cecil

"The cans were impossible for me to open. I tried to feed it a few different times, but no takers I had to have my phones come over to open the cans. I gave a couple of cans to my mom and she told me none of the cats wanted it very disappointed."

Bottom Line

For cats who love tuna, this food might be a hit, but for those who are picky, it might not be worth the price. The mixed feedback and packaging issues make it a challenging recommendation. Note that the value perception is mixed, and the packaging needs improvement to improve user convenience and satisfaction.

6.7 /10
— Average