Pet Food Packaging Issues Trending Down
Firstmate Turkey Formula Limited Ingredient Grain-Free Canned Cat Food

Firstmate Turkey Formula Limited Ingredient Grain-Free Canned Cat Food

By Firstmate 9 reviews analyzed Updated Oct 2023 85% confidence
5.6 /10
Quality
4.6
Value
5.0
Design
4.5
Function
5.2
Durability
5.0

In a Nutshell

  • Food is a bit tropical and generally may not be the best pick for any kind of cat, but it would seem suitable more for particular types of cat or unique situations where partial feeding is going to happen or a fluid base for a senior cat
  • Consider switching if your cat shows no serious indication of moving off the status quo
  • Producer of cans in Chewy seem to have more water during the case stretch out time than to bring out more meaty impression in cats.

Quick Verdict

This cat food receives mixed reviews. Some cats enjoy it, especially those with dental issues or who need a single protein diet. However, many cats refuse to eat it, and it comes with some packaging issues. Its low-protein content leaves some cat owners unsatisfied. Potentially good for picky cats, but back up with another food.

Quick Stats

Reviews Analyzed 9
Would Recommend 44%
Would Buy Again 67%

Pet Compatibility

🐕 Dogs
Suitable
🐈 Cats
Caution

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • High Moisture Content (3)

    Good for seniors, and cats needing a lot of hydration since the texture is semi-solid.

  • Single Protein Source (2)

    Even if this doesn't end up being cat favorite strictly or having something else for sure, it assists cats having good nutrition with no heavy restrictions.

Cons

  • Packing Issues (1) critical

    Problem with cans having cracks around the ripper top lids.

    Tip: Use manual can opener.

  • cats Dislike It (5) minor

    Majority of the cats do not like the smell and the taste of this canned cat food only few buckets to pass with 1 star echoes

Who Is This For?

Best For

  • Seniors cats in need of hydration — Offers right nutritional value and high moisture content.

Skip If

  • cats who are not picky and those that normally jump on anything meaty or for a cat that eats even if it doesn't enjoy. — Most cats dislike the smell and may even avoid eating it.

Durability & Care

Expected Lifespan up to 30 days

Factors: No litter training need since the waste is very very minimal as cats will not need to poop regularly

Cleaning Methods

Machine wash
Hand wash
Spot clean

Care Tips from Users

  • 💡 Use a human grade manual opener instead of the rip one

Floor Compatibility

Hardwood
Tile
Carpet
Vinyl
Laminate

Rating Distribution

2.9
9 reviews
5★
21%
4★
0%
3★
44%
2★
22%
1★
14%
hydration (3) single protein (3) canning issues (5) quality control (2)

Common Questions

Is this food good for cats with dental issues?

Yes, it has high moisture content and is soft, making it easier for cats to eat.

Is this food good for cats with special dietary issues?

It is difficult to say due to mixed reception and customer's transition towards alternate wet food brands available in americana

Cans come with own packaging problem?

Enough to an extent transport may damage them and the strength of plastic pops feels lessening

Highlighted Reviews

— Margie 1 found helpful

"My dog doesn't have a problem with it at all!"

— Nancy

"My cat would not eat! Had to donate"

Bottom Line

This food is best suited towards an older cat who may very well need something a bit creamier in texture or perhaps a cat that has lost most of their teeth. But, for the rest, the kind of food as found in a store as compared to the ones readily available at Chewy is going to make a difference if finances are a consideration. For other cases like bulk buying to resolve the issue, and buying in a different format, making the purchaser not to pay for fats, ounces and other things while most of the wet canned food purchased at Chewy is water, then there doesn't seem to be a complete solution to the problem. The fragrance is also not a great determinant - what may be liked by your cat might not be liked by their smell or taste. It's recommended individual feedback be taken for whether they need a thing or not and should switch the food giving your cat to this brand so as to take advantage of the clearances and added minerals.

5.6 /10
Below Average