This wet cat food is generally well-received, especially for picky eaters. However, there are significant issues with packaging and value for money.
Cats find the taste appealing, even for picky eaters.
Cats find the product appealing, often sticking to this due to medical needs.
It smells exceptionally so for humans.
Users experience frequent packaging issues, such as damaged or leaking containers.
Tip: Check items upon arrival and store carefully.
Several reviewers feel the product is overpriced and not worth the cost, especially when comparing to other brands like Fancy Feast.
Tip: Check alternative selling options
Some buyers are frustrated that the product is not purely seafood.
Tip: Check variety selling options if available
Some reviewers mentioned receiving damaged packaging which is hugely seen affecting the experience
positive
mixed
Factors: Storage, Usage frequency
Product has medicine, but easy to mix with medicines
The usage to be as a trigger upon the medical need.
"This was my Rascal's favorite. Chewy was the only place that you could find it sold by itself. He loved it until the end. He passed away 9/23/2025 at 16 1/2 years old from CKD. He hated CKD moist, and I could mix his medicine in Sheba and he would get his meds. I miss my baby so much it hurts so bad..."
"Ordered this because it’s devised as a 24-twin pack of specifically SIGNATURE SEAFOOD ENTREE, which is all my cat will eat. But it’s just the stupid variety pack that you get at Kroger, so I’m stuck with 18 twin-packs of food she won’t eat. Waste of money. Chewy should be ashamed of themse..."
If your cat loves the flavor and you're okay with occasional packaging issues, this product could be a good fit. Otherwise, you might want to consider alternatives.
High-quality pet food loved by picky eaters but expensive and lacks customer support
Nutritious but picky pets and bone fragments can be issues
Good quality food, but inconsistent user experiences.
Most pets adore this freeze-dried raw food but some struggle with the texture and smell.
Wysong Uncanny Blend offers nutrition but has significant mix issues.
Dave's Cat Food: Good quality, but cats love it or hate it