Pet Supplies active_top_contributor
Herbsmith Smiling Dog Beef Heart Dry-Roasted Dog Treats

Herbsmith Smiling Dog Beef Heart Dry-Roasted Dog Treats

By Herbsmith 14 reviews analyzed Updated Oct 2023 85% confidence
7.6 /10
Quality
7.0
Value
7.5
Design
8.0
Function
8.5
Durability
7.5

In a Nutshell

  • Highly rated by dogs and owners for taste and natural ingredients.
  • Some reviews mention incorrect product contents and weight.
  • Ideal for training or as a healthy snack, just be cautious about product accuracy.

Quick Verdict

Herbsmith Smiling Dog Beef Heart Dry-Roasted Dog Treats are generally well-received for their taste and health benefits. However, there are concerns about ingredient accuracy and size, which some reviewers found misleading.

Quick Stats

Reviews Analyzed 14
Would Recommend 78%
Would Buy Again 64%
Avg Lifespan N/A

Pet Compatibility

🐕 Dogs
Suitable
🐈 Cats
Caution

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Healthy Ingredients (4)

    These treats are made from a single, natural ingredient, beef heart, which is high in protein and nutrients.

  • High Pet Acceptance (5)

    Many dogs enjoy the taste and often finish the treats quickly.

  • Ideal for Training (3)

    The treats break easily into smaller pieces, making them convenient for positive reinforcement training.

  • Nutritious Snack (3)

    They are a good way to add beef hearts to a dog's diet, providing essential nutrients.

  • Competitive vs. Raw Beef (2)

    These treats are an alternative to fresh beef heart, which can be challenging to get dogs to eat.

Cons

  • Incorrect Contents (2) major

    Some reviews noted the presence of spleen in the product, which was unexpected and not mentioned in the product description.

  • Incorrect Weight (2) major

    There are complaints about the product not weighing as much as advertised, with some reviews stating it was only 2.5 oz instead of 3 oz.

  • High Cost (2) minor

    Some reviewers feel the price is too high for the amount and quality of the product.

  • Selective Pet Acceptance (2) major

    Not all dogs will eat these treats, even when placed on the ground.

Who Is This For?

Best For

  • Dog owners who prioritize natural, single-ingredient treats — The products healthy, natural, single-ingredient composition makes them a suitable treat for discerning pet owners that want a nutritious treat.
  • Owners of dogs with digestive issues or on special diets — These treats can be part of an elimination diet or a special diet for dogs that need nutritional variety.
  • Dog trainers — For those purchasing dog treats for training that need small and easily breakable dog treats for dogs that benefit from positive reinforcement during training, these treats are ideal.

Skip If

  • Pet owners who want to avoid any possible carcass ingredients. — After many reviews where buyers were shocked to find heart and spleen in the product instead of beef heart only.

Durability & Care

Expected Lifespan N/A

Factors: Storage conditions, pet chewing habits.

Cleaning Methods

Machine wash
Hand wash
Spot clean

Care Tips from Users

  • 💡 Store in a cool, dry place to maintain freshness.

Floor Compatibility

Hardwood
Tile
Carpet
Vinyl
Laminate

Rating Distribution

4.4
14 reviews
5★
71%
4★
0%
3★
7%
2★
0%
1★
21%
Healthy (6) Nutritious (5) Incorrect contents (2) Overpriced (4) Incorrect Weight (2)

Common Questions

What is the main ingredient in these treats?

The main ingredient is beef heart, though some reviews mentioned the presence of spleen.

Are these treats suitable for dogs with digestive issues?

Yes, many users report success with dogs on special diets, including elimination diets.

How do these treats compare to fresh beef heart?

Some dogs that reject fresh beef heart accept these treats as an alternative, though the price is considered high by some users.

Highlighted Reviews

— Cathy

"My 6 dogs love these beef hearts, they can't get enough. Since I make their food this is a great way to add beef hearts a needed source of nutrition."

— 1DogMom

"I purchased this product because my 22 most. old pup has digestive issues and is on an "elimination" diet. The Chewy description (ingredients) says Beef Heart, but when I received my order, the ingredients listed are Beef Heart and SPLEEN!!."

Bottom Line

If you're looking for a natural, single-ingredient treat for your dog, these are a good option. However, be aware of potential discrepancies in the product's contents and packaging, and ensure the accuracy meets your expectations.

7.6 /10
Good