Dog Treats
Herbsmith Smiling Dog Beef Liver Dry-Roasted Dog Treats
3.0
/10
Quality
3.0
Value
4.0
Design
3.5
Function
4.0
Durability
2.0
In a Nutshell
- Hard treats may need soaking for small dogs
- Risks of sharp edges and digestive issues for small dogs
- Larger dogs may enjoy them with preprocessing
Quick Verdict
The treats are appreciated by some dogs but too hard for smaller breeds, causing concern about teeth and digestion.
Quick Stats
Reviews Analyzed
2
Would Recommend
50%
Would Buy Again
50%
Avg Lifespan
Unknown
Pet Compatibility
🐕
Dogs
Suitable
🐈
Cats
Caution
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
Soaking method (1)
Treats become softer and edible for the dog when soaked in water.
Cons
-
Too hard for small dogs (1) major
The treats are excessively hard, which poses a risk of tooth damage and cracked teeth.
Tip: Soaking the treats in water
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
- • Owners of large dogs — May find the treats suitable after soaking.
- • Dogs that love beef flavour — Beef flavored treated can attract pet
✗ Skip If
- • Owners of small and puppy dogs — Risks of sharp edges and digestive issues.
Durability & Care
Expected Lifespan
Unknown
Cleaning Methods
✓
Machine wash
✓
Hand wash
✓
Spot clean
Care Tips from Users
- 💡 Soaking the treat in water prior to use
Floor Compatibility
⚠️
Hardwood
⚠️
Tile
⚠️
Carpet
⚠️
Vinyl
⚠️
Laminate
Rating Distribution
3.0
2 reviews
5★
0%
4★
50%
3★
0%
2★
50%
1★
0%
Hard treat (1)
Common Questions
Are these treats safe for small dogs?
No, they are too hard and can cause dental issues for smaller dogs.
Highlighted Reviews
— Treats
"This treat is hard but I soaked them in water prior to giving them to her and she loves it!!"
— Dachshund
"The product was too hard for my small dogs to chew safely with sharp edges that may damage teeth or digestive track."
Bottom Line
If you have a small dog or a puppy, you might want to consider softer treats to ensure safety. Larger dogs might enjoy these treats, but be prepared to soak them first.
3.0
/10
—
Average