Pet Supplies Quality Concerns
Herbsmith Smiling Dog Rabbit & Duck with Broccoli & Cranberry Freeze-Dried Dog Treats

Herbsmith Smiling Dog Rabbit & Duck with Broccoli & Cranberry Freeze-Dried Dog Treats

By Herbsmith 10 reviews analyzed Updated Oct 2023 90% confidence
7.2 /10
Quality
6.5
Value
7.0
Design
7.5
Function
7.5
Durability
6.0

In a Nutshell

  • Dogs and cats love the taste and texture.
  • Treats are messy, crumble easily, and have a fishy smell.
  • Healthy and natural, recommended for pets with allergies.

Quick Verdict

Dogs love these treats, but they are crumbly and have a fishy smell. Overall, a good option for pet owners looking for healthy treats.

Quick Stats

Reviews Analyzed 10
Would Recommend 80%
Would Buy Again 60%
Avg Lifespan 3 months

Pet Compatibility

🐕 Dogs
Suitable
🐈 Cats
Suitable

Critical Warnings

high

Fake expiration dates on packaging.

Prevention: Double-check expiration dates before purchasing.

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Tasty (7)

    Dogs and cats enjoy the flavor and texture.

  • Health Benefits (3)

    Healthy option for pets, especially those with allergies.

  • Great for Training (2)

    Can be used to train pets due to their appealing taste.

Cons

  • Messy (5) minor

    Treas are crumbly and messy to handle.

  • Expensive (1) major

    The treats are relatively expensive.

Quality Trend: Declining

Reasons likely were due the printer wrong batching of products.

Older Reviews Said:

neutral

Newer Reviews Say:

negative

Who Is This For?

Best For

  • Pet owners with allergy-sensitived pets — Dogs and cats like the product, even those with allergies. It is a yummy option for your cat.
  • Pet owners who value natural and healthy treats. — The ingredients are natural and the ingredients are human grade.

Skip If

  • Pet owners uncomfortable with crumbly, messy treats. — The treats are incredibly crumbly and messy.

Durability & Care

Expected Lifespan 3 months to 2 months

Factors: Handling, Environment, Expiration date

Cleaning Methods

Machine wash
Hand wash
Spot clean

Care Tips from Users

  • 💡 Keep in a airtight container.

Floor Compatibility

Hardwood
Tile
Carpet
Vinyl
Laminate

Rating Distribution

4.3
10 reviews
5★
70%
4★
10%
3★
0%
2★
10%
1★
10%
Healthy (4) Tasty (7) Messy (5) Fishes (3) False expiration warning. (1)

Common Questions

Are these treats suitable for dogs with allergies?

Yes, many reviews mention that dogs with food allergies have no issues with these.

Highlighted Reviews

— John

"Dog loves these treats"

— Elena

"My dog either ate duck and rabbit for long time prior to not wanting these dumping that the seal and expiration date had been false dates"

Bottom Line

A good choice for healthy, flavored pet treats despite some drawbacks.

7.2 /10
Good