Poultry Supplement High value for money Favored by many users
McMurray Hatchery Murray's Best Oyster Shell Poultry Supplement, 10-lb tub

McMurray Hatchery Murray's Best Oyster Shell Poultry Supplement, 10-lb tub

By McMurray Hatchery 36 reviews analyzed Updated Oct 2023 95% confidence
8.4 /10
Quality
8.5
Value
8.5
Design
7.0
Function
8.2
Durability
8.0

In a Nutshell

  • Excellent for improving egg shell quality.
  • Convenient and easy to dispense.
  • Good value for money.
  • Some users report sizing issues.

Quick Verdict

McMurray's Best Oyster Shell Poultry Supplement is highly praised for its quality and effectiveness. Most users report improved egg shell quality and strong shells. The convenient bucket dispenses easily, and the product is a good value. However, some users found the shells too large for their poultry to eat comfortably.

Quick Stats

Reviews Analyzed 36
Would Recommend 93%
Would Buy Again 94%
Avg Lifespan 4 months

Pet Compatibility

Critical Warnings

high

Shell pieces too large for some poultry.

Prevention: Break shells into smaller pieces before use.

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Egg Shell Quality (9)

    Improves the quality and strength of egg shells.

  • Value for Money (6)

    Offers great value for the price.

  • Convenient Dispensing (4)

    Easy to dispense from the bucket.

  • Effective Supplement (5)

    Works well as a supplement for poultry.

  • Improves Duck and Rooster Health (3)

    Beneficial for ducks and roosters as well.

Cons

  • Large Shell Size (4) major

    Some users found the shell pieces too large.

    Tip: Users might need to break the shells into smaller pieces before use.

  • Uneven Consumption (3) major

    Some poultry did not take to the supplement.

  • Delayed Acceptance (2) minor

    Some pets took time to get used to the supplement.

    Tip: Mixed with regular food or break the pieces down further

Who Is This For?

Best For

  • Poultry owners looking for egg shell quality — Improves the quality and strength of egg shells
  • Owners of mixed flocks — Beneficial for chickens, roosters, and ducks
  • Caretakers of chickens starting to lay eggs — Helps in producing strong and healthy eggs

Skip If

  • Owners who need smaller shell pieces — Some users reported the pieces being too large

Durability & Care

Expected Lifespan 3-6 months

Factors: Poultry size, Dispensing method, Frequency of use

Cleaning Methods

Machine wash
Hand wash
Spot clean

Care Tips from Users

  • 💡 Keep in a dry place
  • 💡 Ensure proper storage to avoid contamination

Rating Distribution

4.5
36 reviews
5★
81%
4★
3%
3★
3%
2★
0%
1★
14%
egg shell quality (10) value for money (6) convenient bucket (3) effective supplement (5) mixed flocks (3) shell size (4) uneven consumption (3) delayed acceptance (2)

Common Questions

How effective is this oyster shell supplement?

It is highly effective in improving egg shell quality and overall poultry health.

Are the pieces too large for small poultry?

Some users found the pieces too large, especially for smaller birds, but they can be broken down further.

How do you store the supplement?

Store in a dry place, preferably in a covered container.

Does it work for other types of poultry besides hens?

Yes, it is effective for chickens, ducks, and geese as well.

How long does a 10-lb tub last?

It typically lasts 3-6 months, depending on the size of the flock and consumption habits.

Highlighted Reviews

— Shelia

"Thanks so much for sending the oyster shells IN a bucket! I just popped the top off and sat the entire bucket in the hen house. The girls are just starting to lay eggs, so hopefully this will help them make some healthy shells."

— Kay

"The pieces were too large and my chickens wouldn’t eat it."

Bottom Line

This oyster shell supplement is an excellent choice for improving egg shell quality in poultry, but pet owners should be aware of potential sizing issues.

8.4 /10
Excellent