Temptations Classic Seafood Medley Flavor Soft & Crunchy Cat Treats
In a Nutshell
- Cats love the taste of these treats.
- Packaging is fragile and easily crushed during shipping.
- Multiple reviewers reported plastic shards mixed with treats.
- Customer service is responsive to issues.
- Overall experience is satisfactory if the treats are kept in stock.
- Treats can be delivered along with other products in the same package.
Quick Verdict
The Temptations Classic Seafood Medley treats are a hit with cats for their flavor, but the packaging leaves much to be desired. Multiple reviewers reported issues with the box being crushed, leading to treats mixed with plastic shards. Chewy’s customer service is noted for being responsive, but the overall experience is marred by delivery issues. This confusion often asks Cat owners to set up separate auto-ship for the treats.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
Cats Love the Taste (3)
Reviewers consistently report that their cats are enthusiastically attracted to these treats.
-
Good Value (2)
Many users find the treats to be good value for the price.
-
Good for Shelter Cats (2)
The treats are appreciated by shelter-based cat rescue organizations.
-
Good Actual usage Value (2)
The amount of treat is good enough to stack up.
-
Good customer support (2)
Customer support for product replacement and product satisfaction program.
Cons
-
Fragile Packaging (5) major
The packaging is frequently reported as being flimsy and easily crushed.
Tip: Customers recommend shipping treats separately or request expedited shipping, if possible.
-
Damage Reports (3) major
Multiple customers reported receiving crushed or contaminated treats due to failed packaging.
Tip: Contact customer service if the shipping is mangled.
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
- • Cat owners — Cats of all types, even those in shelters, are excited by these treats.
✗ Skip If
- • Owners concerned about packaging integrity — The packaging is frequently reported as being fragile and easily crushed. Handling not very good as described.
Durability & Care
Rating Distribution
Common Questions
Are these treats safe for all cats?
Yes, the treats are safe. All cats enjoy the treat flavor.
Is there potable recommendation/informartion when shipping?
We do suggest shipping separately and e-mailing customer representative.
Highlighted Reviews
"Cats love them. They all come running. The price for the amount you get is also perfect."
"The box of treats in this most recent order arrived shattered inside the larger box, shards of plastic mixed with the treats in the bottom of the cardboard box. Everything else was fine. Please could I get a replacement? I've tried uploading a jpg photo of it, but it won't load for some unknown reas..."
Bottom Line
If you can deal with the packaging issues (or ensure separate shipping), these treats are a hit with cats. Consider setting up a separate auto-shipment to prevent damage. If the packaging concerns disproportionately affect your experience you may want to opt for different treats that ship more securely.