Pet Supplements Quality Concerns Editor's Choice
K9 Select Melatonin 6 MG Peanut Butter Flavored Calming Supplement for Dogs, 120 count

K9 Select Melatonin 6 MG Peanut Butter Flavored Calming Supplement for Dogs, 120 count

By K9 Select 12 reviews analyzed Updated Oct 2023 85% confidence
6.9 /10
Quality
7.0
Value
5.5
Design
6.0
Function
7.0
Durability
6.0

In a Nutshell

  • Mixed results on effectiveness for calming and coat health.
  • Some users report significant improvements, while others find it less effective.
  • Value is considered fair, with mixed opinions on price worthiness.
  • Tablet size can be an issue for some users.

Quick Verdict

The K9 Select Melatonin supplement shows mixed results in calming dogs and improving coat health. Some users report significant improvements, while others find it less effective or cumbersome to administer. The value is considered fair, with a few noting it's worth the price and others finding it overpriced.

Quick Stats

Reviews Analyzed 12
Would Recommend 75%
Would Buy Again 58%
Avg Lifespan Unknown

Pet Compatibility

🐕 Dogs
Suitable
🐈 Cats
Caution

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Effective Calming (4)

    Some users report significant calming effects, especially for anxiety related to thunder.

  • Improved Coat Health (2)

    Several users noticed improvements in coat health and hair loss.

  • Ease of Use (2)

    Some users find it easy to administer.

Cons

  • Ineffective for Some (4) major

    Some users report no significant calming effects or other benefits.

  • Tablet Size (3) minor

    Some users find the tablets too small, necessitating them to halve the pills.

    Tip: Halve the tablets and use a pill pocket

  • High Price (1) minor

    Several users think the product is overpriced.

Who Is This For?

Best For

  • Dog owners with anxious pets — It helps with calming during thunderstorms or other stressful situations.

Skip If

  • Owners looking for a quick fix — Some users report that it takes time to see results.
  • Owners with pets that dislike peanut butter — The supplement has a peanut butter flavor, which some dogs may not like.

Durability & Care

Expected Lifespan Unknown

Factors:

Cleaning Methods

Machine wash
Hand wash
Spot clean

Care Tips from Users

  • 💡

Rating Distribution

4.0
12 reviews
5★
42%
4★
25%
3★
17%
2★
17%
1★
0%
calming (4) coat improvement (2) ease of use (2) ineffective (3) tablet size (3)

Common Questions

Does this product work for calming dogs?

Some users report it helps with calming, especially during thunderstorms, but others find it ineffective.

Does it improve coat health?

Some users notice improvements in coat health and hair loss, but results vary.

How do I administer the tablets?

Some users recommend using a pill pocket to make it easier to give the supplement to their dogs.

Highlighted Reviews

— Megan

"Our Old English Bulldog (6yr old male) had had some skin irritations since we brought him home about 2 years ago. He had allergy related skin issues that seemed to calm once he started a regular regimen of Apoquel, but his coat was always pretty thin, in some spots enough to see scarring from his pr..."

— Janice

"Prior bottle had large chewable melatonin which worked like a charm. Now we have to halve the pills (1/2 tablet q.12). We give half a tablet in the a.m. now in a pill pocket (added expense). I THOUGHT i HAD ORDERED THE SAME AS WE HAD."

Bottom Line

If you're looking for a supplement to help calm your dog or improve coat health, the K9 Select Melatonin is a reasonable option, but manage your expectations based on the mixed reviews. It may not be as effective for all dogs, and the size of the tablets can be a drawback.

6.9 /10
Below Average