Treats Mentioned several times by a high number of customers. Trending Down
Icelandic+ Beef Collagen Mini Puffs with Fish Crunchy Cat Treats, 0.5-oz bag

Icelandic+ Beef Collagen Mini Puffs with Fish Crunchy Cat Treats, 0.5-oz bag

By Icelandic+ 12 reviews analyzed Updated Jan 2024 75% confidence
5.2 /10
Quality
5.0
Value
4.5
Design
4.0
Function
6.0
Durability
5.0

In a Nutshell

  • There is an overall negative sentiment with the majority of reviewers stating their cats avoided the treats.
  • The problematic texture, smell and large sizes were often mentioned as points of dissatisfaction.
  • The fairly few who mentioned positive health aspects weren't enough to counter the overwhelmingly negative feedback.

Quick Verdict

The majority of cats do not like the texture and size of these treats. They are often spit out and not preferred by most cats.

Quick Stats

Reviews Analyzed 12
Would Recommend 42%
Would Buy Again 9%
Avg Lifespan Not specified

Pet Compatibility

πŸ• Dogs
Caution
🐈 Cats
Caution

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Quality (1)

    Some owners mentioned the treats are of high quality and healthy for cats.

Cons

  • Size (3) major

    Several cats spit out the treats due to their size, mentioning difficulty in chewing them.

    Tip: Breaking treats into smaller pieces.

  • Texture (3) major

    Multiple reviewers complained that their pets showed no interest in the treats, possibly due to the texture.

  • Smell (1) major

    The extreme chemical smell was perceived as too artificial, causing cats, especially the non fussy ones, to not eat it.

  • Higher aspirations (0) major

    Owners could not find any brand that would compare positively compared to this one, comparing negatively even when broken.

  • Expensive (0) critical

    Owners lament the fact that these expensive do not stand a chance in the market of light smells, definitely not even rewarded by cats.

Who Is This For?

βœ“ Best For

  • β€’ Cat owners looking for healthy, crunchy treats. β€” Some cats found the treats acceptable, though they are not widely popular.

βœ— Skip If

  • β€’ Owners with picky cats or those who prefer smooth textures. β€” The majority of cats seemed to dislike the texture and size of the treats.

Durability & Care

Expected Lifespan Not specified

Cleaning Methods

βœ— Machine wash
βœ— Hand wash
βœ— Spot clean

Floor Compatibility

βœ“ Hardwood
βœ“ Tile
⚠️ Carpet
βœ“ Vinyl
βœ“ Laminate

Rating Distribution

1.6
12 reviews
5β˜…
17%
4β˜…
8%
3β˜…
0%
2β˜…
25%
1β˜…
50%
big parts (3) smell (1) number of cats (0) lost money (0)

Common Questions

How much bigger are these treats compared to other brands?

Mentioned to be quite larger than their equivalents in other brands, causing most of the pets to rip out these treats.

Would cats enjoy having these treats?

Treats are generally disliked by cats. They are generally spit out and cats show no interest in the treats irrespective of being broken.

Highlighted Reviews

β€” Linda

"My cats did not like these, but a friend of mine gave them to his cats. They like them, and his elderly cat seems to have helpedthem. Health stalemates."

β€” Kirston

"None of the cats really liked it. I don’t know if it was the texture or if the pieces were just too big. I tried breakingit up and they would put it in their mouth and spit it back out. I wouldn’t buy it again."

Bottom Line

Generally, this product is not recommended for most cats due to the negative responses and the difficulty in finding cats that enjoy these treats. Some owners tried breaking them into smaller pieces, but this did not improve their cats' acceptance of the treats.

5.2 /10
β€” Below Average